The First Pitch
S2 · Ep 1·Nov 16, 2026·51 min

Allison Pickens, Allison Pickens Ventures

Summary

Before Allison Pickens backed 9 unicorns, she had to convince investors to back her. To open Season 2 of The First Pitch, Patrick Thompson sits down with incoming co-host Allison Pickens to revisit the original pitch behind The New Normal Fund, the assumptions she tested, and how her approach evolved into Allison Pickens Ventures.

As Gainsight’s former COO, Allison helped scale the company from $1M to $85M ARR before its $1B exit. She has since raised approximately $75M across her funds and invested early in 9 companies that went on to achieve unicorn status.

Allison shares how she turned her operating experience into an investment business, why she stopped relying on other VCs’ conviction, and what she looks for in founders before writing a check. They also explore category creation, her decision to back Clarify’s challenge to Salesforce, and how AI is changing the demands of building a company.

Key takeaways

  • Pitch the fund like a product, then let it evolve. Allison first pitched The New Normal Fund as a rough index of top VC-backed startups. Today the pitch is simpler and more personal: a thought partner on go-to-market and scaling, backed by the operating record that got her into those rounds in the first place.
  • Build your own conviction. Early on she leaned on other VCs’ signal to pick companies; the business only became her own once she developed an independent view, wrote bigger checks, and questioned ownership targets and other rules she had inherited from traditional venture.
  • The right founders make categories appear. From Gainsight’s category creation to backing Clarify’s challenge to Salesforce, Allison looks for founders who are forces of nature — and for AI startups, she digs into moats, market risk, and whether seat-based SaaS pricing still holds.